So, what exactly are chargebacks?

A chargeback occurs when a customer disputes a transaction with their credit card company, asking for their money back. Essentially, it reverses a sale that was originally approved. While chargebacks were originally designed to protect consumers from fraud, they’ve evolved into a challenge for legitimate businesses—especially in the ecommerce space, where disputes can occur for a variety of reasons, including dissatisfaction with a product or service, confusion over billing, or even fraud by the customer.

A common mistake merchants make is thinking that winning a chargeback case won’t damage their merchant account. Unfortunately, whether a chargeback is legitimate or not is irrelevant. High chargeback ratios—regardless of the outcome—can still harm your standing with payment processors. Even if you successfully dispute a chargeback, a high volume of chargeback reports alone is enough to jeopardize your ability to process online payments, putting your entire business at risk.

‍

Navigating the Chargeback Minefield: Card Brand Rules and Consequences
‍

The world of chargebacks can feel like a confusing maze. Each card brand (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover) has its own set of rules, regulations, and thresholds for chargebacks. Failing to understand these rules can have severe consequences for your business, extending far beyond the immediate financial loss.

‍

Here’s what’s at stake:

• Increased Operational Costs: Chargeback fees can range from $15 to $100 per case, adding up quickly if you’re handling multiple disputes.

‍

• Merchant Account Termination: Each card brand and payment processor sets a maximum chargeback rate that merchants must stay below. Exceed that threshold, and your merchant account could be terminated, making it incredibly difficult to process payments.

‍

• The MATCH List: Excessive chargebacks can land you on the MATCH (Member Alert to Control High-Risk Merchants) list. This black mark on your reputation can make it significantly harder to secure new payment processing accounts in the future. Merchants typically remain on the MATCH list for five years, during which time it’s very difficult to remove your name. Even after that period, some payment processors may still be wary.

‍

Reputational Damage: A high chargeback rate triggers card brand AI algorithms to flag your transactions. Merchants with a track record of high chargeback ratios are more likely to see new transactions disapproved, resulting in a higher number of declined transactions.

‍

Why Subscriptions Are a Chargeback Magnet

Subscription-based businesses face unique risks when it comes to chargebacks. Because these companies bill customers regularly, the potential for disputes grows over time. Customers may forget they subscribed, misunderstand the terms, or feel that canceling their subscription was too difficult, leading to disputes.

Additionally, some customers engage in what’s known as “friendly fraud”—disputing a legitimate charge simply to avoid payment after enjoying the product or service. Since subscriptions involve recurring billing, chargebacks can escalate quickly if multiple months are disputed, amplifying the financial damage.

This is why managing chargebacks effectively is essential for businesses relying on predictable, recurring revenue.

‍

Fighting Back: A Proactive Approach to Chargeback Prevention

So, how do you tackle the chargeback challenge head-on? It's time to shift from a reactive mindset to a proactive strategy that prioritizes prevention. Here's what you can do:

1. Elevate Your Customer Support:

Exceptional customer service is your first line of defense against chargebacks. A positive customer experience drastically reduces the likelihood of disputes. Here are some key actions:

• Fast and Responsive Email Support: Aim for a 4-hour response time or less to show customers you’re attentive to their needs.

‍

• Accessible Phone Support: Offer phone support during full US business hours to provide a direct and personal channel for resolving issues.

‍

• Frictionless Cancellations and Refunds: Make it easy for customers to cancel subscriptions or request refunds. A smooth process minimizes frustration and reduces the impulse to file a chargeback.
  
  
  

2. Prioritize the First Product Experience:

Remember, first impressions matter. A negative initial product experience significantly increases the chance of future chargebacks, especially in a subscription model where customers are billed repeatedly. Ensure timely delivery, product quality, and clear communication to set the stage for a positive ongoing relationship.

3. Leverage Technology to Your Advantage:

Harnessing the power of technology can be a game-changer in preventing disputes from escalating into chargebacks:

• Chargeback Prevention Alerts: Use tools like RDR and Ethoca, which notify you of potential chargebacks in real-time, allowing you to resolve disputes before they escalate. These systems help flag high-risk transactions so you can take action proactively.

‍‍

• Monitor Chargeback Activity with Math: Merchants need to track the chargeback ratios required by each card brand and understand how their transaction mix impacts these ratios. For example, subscription transactions often have higher chargeback ratios compared to physical product sales. If a merchant stops selling physical products and only processes subscription transactions in a given month, they could experience a spike in their overall chargeback ratio. By understanding how shifts in transaction types affect chargeback activity, merchants can better anticipate and manage these fluctuations to stay within acceptable thresholds.
  
  

• Pre-authorize High Risk Transactions: One of the unique features of Phoenix’s patent-pending subscription OS is its ability to pre-authorize high-risk transactions, similar to how hotels pre-authorize a credit card when you check in. Just as you’re not charged for incidentals unless used, our system ensures high-risk transactions are pre-authorized before being processed. This way, if a customer later attempts a chargeback, it results in a void rather than a full chargeback. This proactive measure significantly reduces chargeback exposure while maintaining customer satisfaction.
  ‍

‍

The Phoenix Advantage: Your Partner in Chargeback Prevention

Building a robust chargeback prevention system requires expertise, time, and resources. Partnering with a specialized solution provider like Phoenix can give you a significant advantage.

At Phoenix, we've made chargeback prevention a core focus. Our platform and services are designed to empower e-commerce businesses to minimize risk, protect their revenue, and build a more secure financial future.

Here's what we deliver:

• Exceptional Customer Support: Our dedicated team provides 24/7 phone and email support, ensuring your customers always have a reliable channel for assistance.

‍

• Dynamic Pre-Authorization Strategy: We implement customized pre-authorization strategies based on your specific business needs and risk profile, helping to mitigate fraud and optimize cash flow.

‍

• Robust, Cycle-Based Analytics and Projections: Our platform provides detailed insights into chargeback trends and patterns, segmented by subscription cycle, allowing you to identify areas for improvement and develop targeted solutions.

‍

Read to make chargeback issues a thing of the past and protect your recurring revenue?

Schedule a call with our team today to see if you’re a right fit!

‍

‍